Review form

Review form

The review form is available on OJS Platform and is structured as follows:

Title of the article:

  1. Assessment of the originality of the subject matter and scientific value of the text. The article extends the existing state of knowledge on the subject:
    1. significantly;
    2. sufficiently;
    3. averagely;
    4. insufficiently.
  2. The content and the text are:
    1. distinctive;
    2. good;
    3. satisfactory;
    4. unsatisfactory.
  3. The arguments put forward:
    1. completely convincing;
    2. largely convincing;
    3. not very convincing;
    4. completely unconvincing.
  4. Literature overview is:
    1. completely satisfactory;
    2. sufficiently;
    3. needs revision and extension.
  5. Assessment of Language and Style. The text is:
    1. Correct and appropriate;
    2. Requires minor corrections;
    3. Requires substantial revisions;
    4. Unsatisfactory.
  6. Comments and Suggestions:
    ……………………………………………………………………
  7. Reviewer’s Recommendation:
    1. The text is suitable for publication;
    2. The text is suitable for publication after minor corrections;
    3. The text may be published after substantial revisions and approval by the Editorial Board;
    4. The text is not suitable for publication.
COVER

Vol. 8 (2024)
Published: 2024-12-30



eISSN: 0000-0000
Logo DOI 10.31261/PP_SoT

Publisher
Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Śląskiego | University of Silesia Press

Licence CC
This website uses cookies for proper operation, in order to use the portal fully you must accept cookies.