The Roma Genocide. The Roma Pariahs before, during, and after the Second World War

Monika Weychert

doi:10.31261/NoZ.2020.06.08

Published: 2020-11-21

No. 6 (2020)

The Roma Genocide. The Roma Pariahs before, during, and after the Second World War

Monika Weychert

Section: The Shoah and Other Genocides

https://doi.org/10.31261/NoZ.2020.06.08

Abstract

The term “pariah” was used by Max Weber in his Ancient Judaism (published originally in the years 1917–1919) to describe the Jewish nation which, as he maintained, was
“separated, formally or de facto, from their social surroundings.” Inspired by Weber’s work, Hannah Arendt was the first to expand this concept to include the Roma people, albeit unwittingly. In the light of Arendt’s essay “The Jew as Pariah: A Hidden Tradition,” the pariah is a “suspect” treated in accordance with the rules of an investigation, examination, or inspection. Constantly watched, spied on, or kept under surveillance, the pariah becomes hypervisible. The Roma pariahs have been immersed in the “ecology of fear” for ages. Never immune to accusations such as theft or fraud, they have always been construed as the criminogenic element of the society. The “suspicion” would all too easily turn into “prevention,” which would frequently take very radical forms. However, it was only in 1987 that the book The Pariah Syndrome: An Account of Gypsy Slavery and Persecution by Ian Hancock cast light directly onto the Roma pariah. The figure of the pariah helps to reveal the essence of the uniqueness of Porajmos – the Roma genocide as a genocide parallel to the Shoah, yet driven by different causes, proceeding along a different course, and burdened with different consequences. One of these consequences was the fact that in the post-war period the extermination of the Roma gradually sank into oblivion and, thereby, into invisibility.

Keywords:

the Roma Genocide , Porajmos , the Roma people , pariah , unsettlement

Download files

PDF

Citation rules

Weychert, M. (2020). The Roma Genocide. The Roma Pariahs before, during, and after the Second World War. Narracje O Zagładzie [Narrations of the Shoah], (6), 140–164. https://doi.org/10.31261/NoZ.2020.06.08

Cited by / Share

References

Abdikeeva A.: Germany’s Policies toward Sinti and Roma: Living Apartheid? The European Roma Rights Centre (ERRC) 2002, http://www.errc.org/article/germanys-policies-toward-sinti-and-roma-living-apartheid/777 [accessed 15.09.2017].
Google Scholar

Abdikeeva A.: Roma Poverty and the Roma National Strategies: The Cases of Albania, Greece and Serbia. London 2005.
Google Scholar

Agamben G.: Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life. Trans. D. Heller-Roazen. Stanford 1998.
Google Scholar

Agier M. (ed.): Un monde de camps. Paris 2014.
Google Scholar

Agier M.: Managing the Undesirables. Trans. D. Fernbach. Cambridge 2011.
Google Scholar

Arendt H.: “The Jew as Pariah: A Hidden Tradition.” Jewish Social Studies 1944 (Apr.), vol. 6, no. 2.
Google Scholar

Arendt H.: The Origins of Totalitarianism. San Diego–New York–London 1973.
Google Scholar

Baker D., Hlavajova M. (eds.): We Roma: A Critical Reader in Contemporary Art. Utrecht 2012.
Google Scholar

Bauman Z.: Europe. An Unfinished Adventure. Cambridge 2004.
Google Scholar

Baumgartner G.: “Austrian Roma under the Holocaust and the Problems of Restitution.” In: Holocaust Era Assets: Conference Proceedings. Prague, June 26–30, 2009. Prague 2009, https://www.lootedart.com/web_images/pdf2018/1.1.4%20Holocaust_Era_Assets_Conference_Proceedings_2009.pdf [accessed 24.04.2020].
Google Scholar

Baumgartner G.: “The Process of Exclusion and Persecution of Roma and Sinti in the 1930s and 1940s.” In: The Roma between the Past and Future. Reflections upon Genocide, Recognition and the Resurgence of Extremism and Anti-Gypsyism. Report on Conference. De Nieuwe Kerk, Amsterdam, The Netherlands: NIOD/Holocaust and Genocide Studies, Anne Frank House, International Gypsy Festival, May 6th, 2012.
Google Scholar

Bercovici K.: The Story of the Gypsies. London 1930.
Google Scholar

Bogdal K.-M.: Europa erfindet die Zigeuner: Eine Geschichte von Faszination und Verachtung. Berlin 2011.
Google Scholar

Borek P. (ed.): Romowie w Polsce i Europie. Kraków 2007.
Google Scholar

Brooks E.: “Reclaiming: The Camp and the Avant-Garde.” In: D. Baker, M. Hlavajova (eds.): We Roma: A Critical Reader in Contemporary Art. Utrecht 2012.
Google Scholar

Bukowski K.: Sterylizacja ludności romskiej 1943–1945 w Bydgoszczy, Dobiegniewie, Pile i Złotowie. Szczecinek 2012.
Google Scholar

Colijn G.J., Sachs Littell M. (eds.): Confronting the Holocaust: A Mandate for the 21st Century. Lanham 1997.
Google Scholar

Dębicki E.: [A statement]. Kwartalnik Romski 2012, vol. 7/2.
Google Scholar

Dębski J., Talewicz-Kwiatkowska J.: Prześladowania i masowa zagłada Romów podczas II wojny światowej w świetle relacji i wspomnień. Kraków 2008.
Google Scholar

Desbois P.: “The Holocaust by Bullets,” https://www.un.org/en/holocaustremembrance/docs/pdf/chapter7.pdf [accessed 22.05.2020].
Google Scholar

Dillman A.: Zigeuner-Buch, zum amtlichen Gebrauche im Auftrage das K. B. Staatsministerius das Innem. München 1905, https://archive.org/details/zigeunerbuch01dill/page/n1/mode/2up [accessed 21.04.2020].
Google Scholar

Dowd S.: “On the Road. Siobhan Dowd on the New European Romani Library and Gypsies in Literature.” The Guardian International Edition 2002, https://www.theguardian.com/books/2002/feb/09/classics.
Google Scholar

Dźwigoł R.: “Stereotyp Cygana w języku polskim.” In: P. Borek (ed.): Romowie w Polsce i Europie. Kraków 2007.
Google Scholar

Epstein Nord D.: Gypsies and the British Imagination, 1807–1930. New York 2006.
Google Scholar

Fraser A.: The Gypsies. 2nd ed. Oxford, UK‒Cambridge, USA 1995.
Google Scholar

Friedman A.J. (ed.): Roads to Extinction. Essays on the Holocaust. New York 1980.
Google Scholar

Friedman P.: “The Extermination of the Gypsies: Nazi Genocide of an Aryan People.” In: A.J. Friedman (ed.): Roads to Extinction. Essays on the Holocaust. New York 1980.
Google Scholar

“Gießen (Stolperstein Klein).” Na Bister!, http://muzeum.tarnow.pl/na-bister/en/giesen-stolperstein-klein-2/ [accessed: 5.08.2018].
Google Scholar

Hancock I.: The Pariah Syndrome: An Account of Gypsy Slavery and Persecution. Revised ed. Ann Arbor 1987.
Google Scholar

Hancock I.: “The Roots of Antigypsyism: To the Holocaust and after.” In: G.J. Colijn, M. Sachs Littell (eds.): Confronting the Holocaust: A Mandate for the 21st Century. Lanham 1997, http://radoc.net/radoc.php?doc=art_b_history_rootsofprejudice&lang=en&articles=true [accessed 21.04.2020].
Google Scholar

Hoess R.: Commandant of Auschwitz. The Autobiography of Rudolf Hoess. Introduction by Lord Russell of Liverpool, C.B.E., M.C. Trans C. FitzGibbon. Cleveland‒New York 1959.
Google Scholar

Horvath F.: [Letter “Daher habe ich mich kurz entschlossen, die hohe Reichsregierung anzurufen,”] Self-evidence, German Reich (Ostmark), May 12, 1938, voi_00023. Rights held by Franz Horvath. Provided by Documentation Centre of Austrian Resistance (Vienna/Austria) Archived under: 12.543, https://www.romarchive.eu/en/collection/daher-habe-ich-mich-kurz-entschlossen-die-hohe-reichsregierung-anzurufen/ [accessed 22.04.2020].
Google Scholar

Kapralski S.: “Milczenie, pamięć, tożsamość. Fantazmat „Cygana” i ambiwalencja nowoczesności.” Ethos 2016, no. 113.
Google Scholar

Kapralski S.: Naród z popiołów. Pamięć zagłady a tożsamość Romów. Warszawa 2012.
Google Scholar

Kogălniceanu M.: Esquisse sur l’histoire, les moeurs et la langue des Cigains. Berlin 1837.
Google Scholar

Kolberg O.: Chełmskie. Reprint. Kraków 1980.
Google Scholar

Krzyżanowski J.: Polska bajka ludowa w układzie systematycznym. Wrocław 1963.
Google Scholar

Liégeois J.-P.: Roma, Gypsies, Travellers. Trans. S. ní Shuinéar. Strasbourg 1994.
Google Scholar

Linde S.: Słownik języka polskiego. Vols 1–6. Warszawa 1807–1814.
Google Scholar

Lockwood W.G., Salo S.M.G.: Gypsies and Travelers in North America: An Annotated Bibliography. Cheverly, MD 1994.
Google Scholar

Matras Y.: The Romani Gypsies. Cambridge, MA 2015.
Google Scholar

Mayer-Benedek A.: Schicksal der Burgenlandroma mit Blick auf Mattersburg, http://www.70haus.at/buch/roma/roma.pdf [accessed 21.04.2020].
Google Scholar

Mbembe A.: Necropolitics. Trans. S. Corcoran. Durham‒London 2019.
Google Scholar

Milton S.: “Persecuting the Survivors. The Continuity of ‘Anti-Gypsyism’ in Post-war Germany and Austria.” In: S. Tebbutt (ed.): Sinti and Roma. Gypsies in German-Speaking Society and Literature. New York–Oxford 2008.
Google Scholar

Mróz L.: Geneza Cyganów i ich kultury. Warszawa 1992.
Google Scholar

“Mühlstraße 8 (ehem. Löwengasse 23) ‒ Ferdinand Klein.” Gießen Rathaus, https://www.giessen.de/index.php?ModID=7&FID=2874.1345.1&object=tx%7C2874.1345.1 [accessed 21.05.2018].
Google Scholar

Nawrocki G.: “Cintis in Hamburg: Grossstadt-Zigeuner Ohne Romantik.” Hamburger Tagenblatt 1937 (18–20 Aug.), pp. 223–225, http://www.minderheiten.org/roma/index2.html; http://www.minderheiten.org/roma/ueberblick/2.2.timeline.htm [accessed 21.04.2020].
Google Scholar

Our Romani History, http://www.varromskahistoria.se/en/forced-integration/black-wednesday [accessed 18.04.2020].
Google Scholar

Pollack M.: “Nie ma tablicy pamiątkowej dla Romów. Pamięć i milczenie w Burgenlandzie.” Studia Romologica 2012, no. 5.
Google Scholar

Portnow A.: “Czy Ukraina jest gotowa wydorośleć? Spostrzeżenia na temat Holokaustu w polityce i pamięci historycznej.” In: Światła w Ciemności – Sprawiedliwi wśród Narodów Świata. Lublin 2010.
Google Scholar

Portschy T.: [Denkschrift zur „Zigeunerfrage” vom August 1938], Eisenstadt, August 1938, http://www.kurt-bauer-geschichte.at/PDF_Lehrveranstaltung%202008_2009/E11_Portschy_Zigeunerfrage.pdf [accessed 22.04.2020].
Google Scholar

Powell R.: “Understanding the Stigmatization of Gypsies: Power and the Dialectics of (Dis)identification.” Housing, Theory and Society 2008, vol. 25, no. 2, pp. 87–109, DOI: 10.1080/14036090701657462.
Google Scholar

Republik Österreich, Bundesministerium für Inneres, Generaldirektion für die Öffentliche Sicherheit, BMI Zl.84-426-4/48 vom 20.9.1948
Google Scholar

Runderlaß des Reichsführers SS und Chefs der Deutschen Polizei im Reichsministerium des Inneren, Heinrich Himmler, von 8.12.1938 über die “Bekämpfung der Zigeunerplage.“ Ministerialblatt des Reichs- und Preußischen Ministeriums des Innern, 1938, Nr. 51, Spalten 2105–2106, https://geschichte-bewusst-sein.de/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/SNG_014_RZ_Zusatz12-2017-02-23.pdf [accessed 22.05.2020].
Google Scholar

Seltzer M.: True Crime. Observations on Violence and Modernity. New York 2007 (2011).
Google Scholar

Sobieska A.: Dzieci Hagar. Literackie wizerunki Romów/Cyganów. Studia imagologiczne. Warszawa 2015.
Google Scholar

Strożek P.: “Chaplinada w kręgach lewicy literackiej i artystycznej lat 20.” Kwartalnik Filmowy 2015 (spring–summer), no. 89–90.
Google Scholar

Talewicz-Kwiatkowska J.: “Holokaust Romów. Czy rzeczywiście zapomniany?” Nigdy Więcej 2016, no. 22.
Google Scholar

Tebbutt S . (ed.): Sinti and Roma. Gypsies in German-Speaking Society and Literature. New York–Oxford 2008.
Google Scholar

Thurner E., Hussl E., Eder-Jordan B. (eds.): Roma und Travellers. Identitäten im Wandel. Introduction by K.-M. Gauss. Innsbruck 2015, https://www.uibk.ac.at/iup/buch_pdfs/roma-und-travellers/10.152032936-95-0.pdf [accessed 22.05.2020].
Google Scholar

Thurner E.: “Roma in Europa, Roma in Österreich.” In: E. Thurner, E. Hussl, B. Eder-Jordan (eds.): Roma und Travellers. Identitäten im Wandel. Introduction by K.-M. Gauss. Innsbruck 2015, https://www.uibk.ac.at/iup/buch_pdfs/roma-und-travellers/10.152032936-95-0.pdf [accessed 22.05.2020].
Google Scholar

Traverso E.: The Origins of Nazi Violence. Trans. J. Lloyd. New York‒London 2003.
Google Scholar

Tyrnauer G.: “‘Mastering the Past’: Germans and Gypsies.” In: F. Chalk, K. Jonassohn (eds.): The History and Sociology of Genocide. Analyses and Case Studies. New Haven–London 1990.
Google Scholar

Wat A.: “Charlie Chaplin. Pamflet czy omlet?” Awangarda 1924, no. 1.
Google Scholar

Weber M.: Ancient Judaism. Trans. and ed. H.H. Gerth, D. Martindale. London 1952.
Google Scholar

Wolfe S.: The Politics of Reparations and Apologies. New York–Heidelberg–Dordrecht–London 2014.
Google Scholar

Zimmermann M.: Verfolgt, vertrieben, vernichtet, Die nationalsozialistische Vernichtungspolitik gegen Sinti und Roma. Essen 1989.
Google Scholar

No. 6 (2020)
Published: 2020-11-23

ISSN: 2450-4424

eISSN: 2451-2133

Publisher

Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Śląskiego | University of Silesia Press

Submit

The Roma Genocide. The Roma Pariahs before, during, and after the Second World War

Abstract

Keywords:

Monika Weychert

Information