The Polish experiment 1980—1989 — revolution or transformation? Antinomies of transition from authoritarianism to democracy

Zbigniew Kantyka

Opublikowane:

Tom 13 (2014)

The Polish experiment 1980—1989 — revolution or transformation? Antinomies of transition from authoritarianism to democracy

Zbigniew Kantyka

Abstrakt

Abstract: The article is an attempt to assess some of the key aspects of the Polish breakthrough of 1980–1989 in the context of the many years of discussion about the nature and consequences of the events that took place during that period. The main considerations include resolving the still valid dilemma of whether it is justified to define this breakthrough as a revolution. The text contains a presentation and evaluation of the main arguments made for and against such a conclusion. In methodological terms, the discourse involves confronting the characteristic features relating to the genesis, goals, process and results of the Polish experiment of 1980—1989, with the theoretical knowledge on the phenomenon of the revolution based on historical analyses and contemporary experience. In science, the term “experiment” is usually used to describe cognitive processes involving an intentional interference of the researcher in the real world in order to acquire cognitive data. It happens, however, that certain unique phenomena and processes characterised by an objective course of events, which scientists can analyse in similar terms to a conventional induced experiment, enter the scope of this concept. In certain circumstances, a systematic observation of events which have not been induced by the researcher, but are exceptional and important in themselves, can provide the key to discovering the sense, regularities, and mechanisms of the real world. This is significant for social and political studies in particular, in which the space for utilising the classical, natural sciences‑based experiment, is very limited.

The Polish political events of 1980—1989 made way for further disintegration of the colonial‑imperial division of the world by initiating the fall of the Eastern Bloc. It turned out to be not just an episode, but an effective initiation of a powerful and extensive process that led to a total change in the global geopolitical system. The fact that it happened in the centre of Europe, rather than in its peripheries, exacerbated the surprise of such a course of events, and of its final result in particular.

Key words: democratic transformation, revolution, post‑totalitarian authoritarianism, Solidarity movement, Self‑Governing Republic

Pobierz pliki

PDF

Zasady cytowania

Kantyka, Z. (2017). The Polish experiment 1980—1989 — revolution or transformation? Antinomies of transition from authoritarianism to democracy. Studia Politicae Universitatis Silesiensis, 13. Pobrano z https://journals.us.edu.pl/index.php/SPUS/article/view/5465

Bibliografia

After the Collapse of Communism: Comparative Lessons of Transition. Eds. M. McFaul, K. StonerWeiss. Cambridge 2004.
Google Scholar

Arendt H.: Kondycja ludzka. Warszawa 2000.
Google Scholar

Arendt H.: On Revolution. London 1973.
Google Scholar

Ash T.G.: The Magic Lantern. The Revolution of ’89 Witnessed in Warsaw, Budapest, Berlin, and Prague. Cambridge 1993.
Google Scholar

Ash T.G.: The Polish Revolution: Solidarity 1980—1982. London 1983.
Google Scholar

Bandelj N.: From Communists to Foreign Capitalists: The Social Foundations of Foreign of Foreign Direct Investments in Postsocialist Europe. Princeton 2008.
Google Scholar

Bauman Z.: Intimations of Postmodernity. London 1992.
Google Scholar

Berlin I.: The Sense of Reality: Studies in Ideas and Their History. New York 1996.
Google Scholar

Birch S.: Electoral Systems and Political Transformation in Post-Communist Europe. Basingstoke—New York 2003.
Google Scholar

Buden B.: Strefa przejścia. O końcu postkomunizmu. Warszawa 2012.
Google Scholar

Bunce V.: “Rethinking Recent Democratization: Lessons from the Postcommunist Experience.” World Politics 2003, Vol. 55, No. 2.
Google Scholar

Central and East European Politics. From Communism to Democracy. Eds. S.L. Wolchik, J.L. Curry. Lanham 2011.
Google Scholar

Cirtautas A.M.: The Polish Solidarity Movement: Revolution, Democracy and Natural Rights. London 1997.
Google Scholar

Ciżewska E.: Filozofia publiczna Solidarności. Warszawa 2010.
Google Scholar

Clark T.D.: Beyond Postcommunist Studies: Political Science and the New Democracies of Europe. New York 2002.
Google Scholar

Dahl R.: O demokracji. Kraków 2000.
Google Scholar

Democratization in Eastern Europe: Domestic and International Perspectives. Eds. G. Pridham, T. Vanhanen. London 1994.
Google Scholar

Dix R.H.: “Eastern Europe’s Implications for Revolutionary Theory.” Polity 1991, Vol. 24, No. 2.
Google Scholar

Eastern Europe: Transformation and Revolution 1945—1991. Documents and Analyses. Ed. L.H. Legters. Lexington 1992.
Google Scholar

Frank A.G.: “Revolution in Eastern Europe: Lessons for Democratic Social Movements (and Socialists?).” Third World Quarterly 1990, Vol. 12.
Google Scholar

Freedom and Choice in a Democracy: The Difficult Passage to Freedom. Eds. R. Magliola, R. Khuru. Washington 2004.
Google Scholar

Friszke A.: Rewolucja Solidarności 1980—1981. Kraków 2014.
Google Scholar

Geremek B.: “Solidarność jako model wyjścia z komunizmu.” In: Od Solidarności do wolności. 25 lat. Konferencja międzynarodowa. Ed. N. Smolar. Warszawa—Gdańsk 2005.
Google Scholar

Glenn J.K.: “Contentious Politics and Democratization: Comparing the Impact of Social Movements of the Fall of Communism in Eastern Europe.” Political Studies 2003, No. 51.
Google Scholar

Goldman M.F.: Revolution and Change in Central and Eastern Europe. Political, Economic, and Social Challenges. Armonk 1997.
Google Scholar

Goodwyn L.: Jak to zrobiliście? Powstanie Solidarności w Polsce. Gdańsk 1992.
Google Scholar

Heywood A.: Key Concepts in Politics. Basingstoke—London 2000.
Google Scholar

Holzer J.: “„Solidarność” — rewolucja, powstanie czy reforma. Dyskusja panelowa.” In: Solidarność od wewnątrz 1980—1981. Eds. A. Friszke, K. Persak, P. Sowiński. Warszawa 2013.
Google Scholar

Huntington S.: Political Order in Changing Societies. New Heaven 1968.
Google Scholar

Huntington S.: The Third Wave: Democratization in the Late 20th Century. Norman—London 1991.
Google Scholar

Kersten K.: “O użyteczności konceptu totalitaryzmu w badaniach historii PRL.” In: Eadem: Pisma rozproszone. Eds. T. Szarota, D. Libionka. Toruń 2005.
Google Scholar

Kimmel M.S.: Revolution. A Sociological Interpretation. Cambridge 1990.
Google Scholar

Kolasa-Nowak A.: Zmiana systemowa w Polsce w interpretacjach socjologicznych. Lublin 2010.
Google Scholar

Kumar K.: “The Revolutions of 1989 in East-Central Europe and the Idea of Revolution.” In: Culture, Modernity and Revolution. Essays in Honor of Zygmunt Bauman. Eds. R. Kilminster, I. Varcoe. New York 1996.
Google Scholar

Kurczewski J.: “Klasy średnie po latach.” In: Idem: Ścieżki emancypacji. Osobista teoria transformacji ustrojowej w Polsce. Warszawa 2009.
Google Scholar

Linz J.J., Stepan A.: Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation. Southern Europe, South America, and Post-Communist Europe. Baltimore 1996.
Google Scholar

Ludwikowski R.R.: “A New Constitutional Model for East-Central Europe.” In: Freedom and Choice in a Democracy: The Difficult Passage to Freedom. Eds. R. Magliola, R. Khuru. Washington 2004.
Google Scholar

Magala S.: Walka klas w bezklasowej Polsce. Gdańsk 2012.
Google Scholar

Mażewski L.: Posttotalitarny autorytaryzm PRL 1956—1989. Analiza ustrojowopolityczna. Warszawa—Biała Podlaska 2010.
Google Scholar

Offe C.: Drogi transformacji. Doświadczenia wschodnioeuropejskie i wschodnioniemieckie. Warszawa—Kraków 1999.
Google Scholar

Ost D.: “„Solidarność” — rewolucja, powstanie czy reforma. Dyskusja panelowa.” In: Solidarność od wewnątrz 1980—1981. Eds. A. Friszke, K. Persak, P. Sowiński. Warszawa 2013.
Google Scholar

Ost D.: Klęska „Solidarności”. Gniew i polityka w postkomunistycznej Europie. Warszawa 2007.
Google Scholar

Ost D.: Solidarity and the Politics of Anti-Politics. Opposition and Reform in Poland since 1968. Philadelphia 1990.
Google Scholar

Postcommunism and the Theory of Democracy. Eds. R.D. Anderson Jr., M.S. Fish, S.E. Hanson, P.G. Roeder. Princeton 2001.
Google Scholar

Przeworski A.: Democracy and the Market. Political and Economic Reforms in Eastern Europe and Latin America. New York 1991.
Google Scholar

Skórzyński J.: “„Solidarność” — rewolucja, powstanie czy reforma. Dyskusja panelowa.” In: Solidarność od wewnątrz 1980—1981. Eds. A. Friszke, K. Persak, P. Sowiński. Warszawa 2013.
Google Scholar

Sowa J.: “Upadek Polskiej Rzeczpospolitej Ludowej. Demokratyzacja państwa leninowskiego.” In: Idem: Ciesz się, późny wnuku! Kolonializm, globalizacja i demokracja radykalna. Kraków 2008.
Google Scholar

Staniszkis J.: Postkomunizm. Próba opisu. Gdańsk 2001.
Google Scholar

Staniszkis J.: Samoograniczająca się rewolucja. Gdańsk 2010.
Google Scholar

Sułek A.: “O nieprzewidywalności rewolucji. Dlaczego polska socjologia nie przewidziała „Solidarności”.” In: Idem: Obrazy z życia socjologii w Polsce. Warszawa 2011.
Google Scholar

Sułek A.: Eksperyment w badaniach społecznych. Warszawa 1979.
Google Scholar

The Consolidation of Democracy in East-Central Europe. Eds. K. Dawisha, B. Parrott. Cambridge 1997.
Google Scholar

Tilly Ch.: “Rewolucja i rebelia.” In: Władza i społeczeństwo. Ed. J. Szczupaczyński. Warszawa 1995.
Google Scholar

Tilly Ch.: European Revolutions 1492—1992. Oxford 1995.
Google Scholar

Touraine A.: Solidarność. Analiza ruchu społecznego 1980—1981. Gdańsk 2010.
Google Scholar

Transition to Democracy in Poland. Eds. R.F. Staar. Basigstoke 1998 (2nd edn).
Google Scholar

Transitions to Capitalism and Democracy in Russia and Central Europe: Achievements, Problems, Prospects. Ed. M.D. Hancock, J. Logue. Westport 2000.
Google Scholar

Walicki A.: “Totalitaryzm i posttotalitaryzm. Próba definicji.” In: Idem: Polskie zmagania z wolnością. Widziane z boku. Kraków 2000.
Google Scholar

Weiler J.H.H.: “The Transformation of Europe.” The Yale Law Journal 1991, Vol. 100, No. 8.
Google Scholar

Welsh H.A.: “Political Transition Processes in Central and Eastern Europe.” Comparative Politics 1994, Vol. 26, No. 4.
Google Scholar

White S.: Communism and Its Collapse. New York 2001.
Google Scholar

Załęski P.: “Czy Solidarność była społeczeństwem obywatelskim? Jak został zapomniany neorepublikański projekt samorządnej Rzeczypospolitej.” Kultura i Społeczeństwo 2010, No. 4.
Google Scholar

Zarycki T.: “Socjologia krytyczna na peryferiach.” Kultura i Społeczeństwo 2009, No. 1.
Google Scholar

Tom 13 (2014)
Opublikowane: 2017-03-19

ISSN: 1895-3492

eISSN: 2353-9747

10.31261/spus

Wydawca

Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Śląskiego | University of Silesia Press

Prześlij tekst